Can someone rate my sig.

Please rate out of 10.

3 of 10. It could be way better.H.

2/10. There's a huge rectangle thing on the side. That font + colour in no way match the rest of the signature. The effect C4D is way too sharp. You don't really have one specific focal point and it distracts the eye. THe colours match, but there's not enough of them.Keep going.

X4/10I can't see Sora's keyblade which is primary...
Plus, the rectangle in the most right side, doesn't fit well with the main one.Good luck improving it.X

Replying to #4

no it's not, even if the whole keyblade was in the sig it still wouldnt be the focal.but as for the sig... it's real low quality, it has far too many artifacts due to the fact that it's save as a jpeg, try to stick to png. as was already mentioned, theres the wierd rectange bit... which suggests the C4D is only a thumbnail, or you have shrunk it far too much. It's needs a border and the text is mis-placed and the blue doesnt fit it with the rest of the sig. It looks like your a beginner so I think it would be unfair to give you a score out of 10.

Yea i know the blade was like that so i had to put it on the side and i forgot about the rectangle and just remembered when i was finished.

I will rate it a 8/10 because I know I can't make a better one.

i'm not a fan of art but i have to tell that is really nice!

4/10, sorry, it needs a LOT of work :/

Replying to #9

I'd have to rate it much the same.Remove that rectangle and prehaps I'd bump it to 5, but all the other's have mentioned the other weaknesses...Good luck improving it.

ericvang · #7I will rate it a 8/10 because I know I can't make a better one.

Even so, while I'm much the same I rate by my view, not comparing to my skill.I could make comparisons...but the simple thing is, you can still judge even if you lack talent, as long as you make good points about it rather than say 'it's crap' as I seen else where...

this sort of thing should be posted in the signature thread.Locked